12 Difference Between Guidance and Counselling | B.Ed Notes

What are the Difference Between Guidance and Counselling?

Introduction: The terms guidance and counselling are being used in different contexts and can mean anything from informal advice that is often given to close friends to formal counselling undertaken by specially trained professionals.

Guidance is the assistance given to an individual to help him, to adjust to himself, to others and to his own environment. In this way guidance is a process of all-around development.

Counselling refers to professional services provided to an individual who is facing a problem and needs helps to overcome the problem. Counselling considers being an integral part of Guidance. The process of Counselling helps an individual to find the solution to a problem and also helps in the overall development of an individual.

Difference Between Guidance and Counselling

GuidanceCounselling
1The Meaning of Guidance can be understood as “to direct” or “to show the path”Counselling refers to the professional advice provided by a counsellor or therapist to needy individuals so that they can overcome their personal and Psychological Problems
2It is preventive in NatureIt is mostly remedial and curative in Nature
3It is comprehensive and ExtrovertedIt is done in-depth and introverted
4Guidance helps or assists the person to choose the best decisionsCounselling tends to change the perspective, to help him get the solution by himself or herself
5The guidance gives clients ready answersCounselling helps them come up with a well-informed solution
6The guidance uses an external approach to tackle the issue at handCounselling uses the in-depth approach to establish the root cause of the problems before tackling it
7Guidance is the best approach for tackling educational and career problemsCounselling is best employed in tackling socio-psychological and other personal problems
8It can be provided by any person who is experienced in a particular field or expertCounselling is mostly provided by Trained professional
9This is less private or confidentiality is not guaranteedThis is mostly confidential
10This can be given to individuals or in a groupThis gives one to one
11Guidance can be given from Schools, home; everywhere; womb to tomb.Counselling is given in a special setting conducive to giving and receiving help for interviewing
12The main purpose of the guidance is to Optimum development of individual students for the ultimate development of the schoolThe main Purpose of Counselling is to Help individuals develop self-confidence and adjust to life strategies and schooling problems

Definition of Guidance and Counselling

Meaning and Definition of Guidance

To Guide means to indicate, to point out, and to show the way. It means more than to assist. A man falls in the Street, we assist him to get up but we do not guide him unless we help him to go in a certain direction.

Guidance involves personal help given by someone. It is designed to assist a person to decide where he wants to go?. What does he want to do? Or how he can accomplish his purpose. The focus of the guidance is on individuals, not on the problems. The main Purpose of Guidance is to promote the Growth of an Individual in Self-direction.

Definition of Guidance is given by different Scholars are given Below-

  1. Ruth Strang: “Guidance is the process of helping every individual, through his own effort, to discover and develop his potentialities for his personal happiness and Social usefulness.
  2. Crow and Crow: “Guidance is Assistance made available by personally and adequately trained Men and Women to an individual of any age to help him manage his own life activities, develop his own point of view, make his own decision and carry his own burdens”
  3. Secondary Education Commission, 1952: “Guidance involves the difficult art of helping boys and girls to plan their own future wisely in the full light of all the factors can be mastered about themselves and about the world in which they are to live and work”

Meaning and Definition of Counselling

Counselling is a dynamic process. It Aims the solution of clients’ problems. It is a process between the counsellor and the clients in which the Solution emerges as a joint venture of two.

The Term counselling meaning in Hindi is “upbodhan” developed by the Commission-Ministry of Education, Government of India. The Term “upbodhan” is derived from the word ‘bodh’ which means Knowledge. The root stem of the word is ‘budhi’ which means Intelligence. The Word “pramashdata’ is also frequently used in Hindi for Counsellor.

The meaning of Counselling becomes more clear through the definition given by Kother and Brown (2000) are-

  • A profession with a history and set of standards, distinct from other related disciplines such as social work, psychology, and psychiatry
  • An Activity that is designed to work with relatively normally functioning individuals who are experiencing developmental or adjustment problems
  • A relationship, whether in a group, family or individual format, is constructed in a way to promotes trust, safety and change.
  • Multidimensional dealing with human feelings, thoughts and behaviours, past, present, and future.

Other definitions are –

  1. Ruth Strang: “Counselling is a face to face relationship in which growth takes place in the counsellor as well as counselee”
  2. Carl Rogers: “Counselling is a process by which the structure of the self is relaxed in the safety of the relationship with the therapist, and previously denied experiences are perceived and then integrated into an altered self”

Key Difference Between Counselling and Guidance

The difference between Counselling and Guidance can be summarized as follows-

  • Counselling is an inward analysis of the individual whereas guidance involves an external analysis of the individual and his problems.
  • Counselling is an in-depth analysis and has a narrower perspective wherein the individual understands his problems in depth whereas guidance is a broader and more comprehensive approach.
  • Counselling is generally provided for personal and social issues whereas guidance is usually provided for education and career-related problems.
  • Counselling focuses on making the individual understand the problem and therefore, it brings about behavioural changes in the individual so that he can adjust to the problem. On the other hand, guidance focus on finding a solution to the problems whereby the solution may bring about a change in the attitude of the individual.
  • In Counselling, The counsellor is not the decision-maker while in Guidance the professional who offers guidance service is the decision-maker
  • While counselling lays emphasis on both learnings as well as feelings, the guidance gives no place to feel and is more of an intellectual process.
  • Counselling leads to what may be termed as self-discovery of the individual whereas guidance does not lead to self-discovery of an individual

Conclusion

We can conclude from the above discussion that, Guidance and counselling are both involved with the development of an individual who is facing and solving the problems. Guidance and counselling depend on each other.

However, despite the fact that both guidance and counselling are aimed at helping an individual in finding solutions to his problems, there are some differences between the two, especially in terms of how the process is carried out and implemented.

Reference: